Myanmar Ethnic Peace Process: Two Important Studies
Pu Zing Cung said the ethnic groups wanted all factions to sign, including the three blackballed by the government – the Arakan Army, the Ta’ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) and the ethnic Chinese rebels of the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA) fighting in the Kokang border area.
- International community must support peace in Myanmar: Richard Horsey - Financial Times
- Will democracy bring peace to Myanmar: Dr Marte Nilsen - IAS Review Oslo
Derek Tonkin writes: The prospects for an NCA at some time during October 2015 do not look encouraging. An NCA would provide a tremendous boost to the election prospects of the governing USDP and it is unlikely that most ethnic parties would welcome this. Contrary to most analyses, I do not myself believe that all that much would be lost by deferring a signature until the new government is formed in February/March 2016, after the elections. An NCA then might be built on a more solid basis.
This would not be inconsistent with the view expressed in the 'Readout" of the meeting on 29 September of the UNSG's partnership group on Myanmar which noted: "In regard to the peace process, though key differences still remain, Member States welcomed the perseverance shown by all sides in their effort to stabilise a nationwide ceasefire, build trust and move towards the start of a meaningful political dialogue. All stakeholders were urged to remain actively involved in the next stage of negotiations." This would not suggest that partnership members are in any sense holding their breath in expectation.
Latest News and Views
- Vijay Nambiar, Special Adviser on Myanmar to the UN Secretary-General, on the Peace Talks - DVB
- Tentative agreement reached for ceasefire signing next month - The Irrawaddy
- President vows to include warring factions in talks - Democratic Voice of Burma
- Opinion: Divisive cease-fire won't bring peace: Maung Zarni - Democratic Voice of Burma
- Suu Kyi says rebel groups shouldn't rush peace deal - Reuters
- What's holding up Burma's nationwide ceasefire? Maung Zarni - Democratic Voice of Burma
- Myanmar: New front in an old war - The Arakan Army: The Diplomat
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the nationwide ceasefire talks in Burma, and the prospects for peace in the ethnic states, particularly Kachin state.
Professor Taylor notes that "the question of ethnicity in Myanmar politics has obviously been revitalised with the return to open politics and a free press since 2010. Much of the discussion is highly emotional, not grounded in history, and conceptually misleading.....
"Ethnicity since independence has mixed into a political cocktail from which demagogues drink and politicians, rather than providing the public guidance and leadership, do little to drain off except by appeasement.....The issue of ethnicity in Myanmar politics is not now being resolved, but rather encouraged, thus detracting public attention from other concrete issues such as the economy or administrative and legal reform." Read on.....
Myanmar's Ethnic Parties and the 2015 Elections
Marie Lall, Nwe Nwe San,Theint Theint Myat and Yin Nyein Aye
European Union - International Management Group (IMG)
The ethnic political parties were the first legitimate opposition to the Union Solidarity and
Development Party (USDP) dominated assemblies after the 2010 election.The purpose of the
research is to understand the role that ethnic parties play in Myanmar politics today, their views on the reform and peace processes, their thoughts about the Ethnic Armed Groups (EAGs), and the challenges they face for the 2015 elections in light of the NLD's re-entry into politics.
"Separate issues that are muddying the outlook include the long-term and understandable mistrust that the ethnic groups have of the Tatmadaw (armed forces), which has previously committed widespread abuses against minorities. This colours several issues, including the question of integrating ethnic fighters into the army.
"Moving forward, ethnic militia group leaders are expected to review the agreement, after which the government has said that a conference will be held with the aim of securing a final agreement. There is a chance that the process will move swiftly given the natural deadline of November's polls. The situation on the ground, however, highlights the volatility of the situation. Any process of political dialogue is inevitably going to have points of contention. At a very basic level, if the government is serious about a federal system, it is one that has to be inclusive, and as the situation currently stands, there are many ethnic groups that are disenfranchised.
"By the end of this year, the current work of negotiators will leave its successor with either a solid legacy on which to build Myanmar, or a major and continuing headache."
Constitutional reform and nationwide peace will be essential, and it is vital that the conduct of the general election is free and fair to ensure momentum in political reform. An inclusive political dialogue must be fostered at the national level to move beyond the practice of different parliamentary processes and ethnic ceasefire talks that do not provide a political roadmap for all citizens.
The Special Adviser on Myanmar to the UN Secretary-General Mr Vijay Nambiar has welcomed the “milestone” agreement on a text for the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement drawn up by the Union Peace Working Committee and Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team for Myanmar on March 31. The text of his statement reads:
"Today, on the 31st of March 2015, after more than a year of negotiations, the Union Peace Working Committee (UPWC) and Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team (NCCT) have agreed on the text of a Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) for Myanmar. For the government of Myanmar and 16 Ethnic Armed Groups to reach a ceasefire agreement after more than sixty years of conflict is a historic and significant achievement. The United Nations welcomes this milestone in Myanmar's history, and congratulates President U Thein Sein and his negotiators as well as leaders of the Ethnic Armed Organizations and the NCCT.
"As Observers to the process alongside China, the United Nations, through the Office of the Special Adviser to the Secretary-General, have followed the proceedings closely and through difficult as well as lighter moments. Throughout, we have been deeply impressed by the hard work, true determination, genuine commitment and goodwill shown by the UPWC and NCCT. We are deeply honored and humbled to have been invited to observe the parties through their historic deliberations.
"The signing of an NCA is a first step towards a larger dialogue for settling the political and military issues that will pave the way for an inclusive and harmonious future for Myanmar. However it is a crucial first stage that must be crossed before embarking on the next chapter.
"Myanmar is still in a nascent stage of its transition. Today's agreement is a signal that new levels of trust, confidence and cooperation are possible between former enemies and that the seeds of change in Myanmar are beginning to sprout.
"Today's achievement is also remarkable and unusual as a process completely initiated and executed by national stakeholders. While many concerns and difficulties will remain on the ground in Myanmar, this is a day to celebrate as a great achievement and as one that provides a solid basis from which to continue the hard work that will be necessary to achieve a genuine and lasting peace in the country. The United Nations will continue to support and work with the peoples of Myanmar."
- President witnesses signing of draft ceasefire agreement in Yangon
- The devil is in the detail: Mark Inkey - Asian Correspondent
- A meeting of unity in war-torn Myanmar - Globe and Mail (Toronto)
- Myanmar draft ceasefire - reason to be cautiously optimistic - Deutsche Welle
Derek Tonkin writes: The draft ceasefire is the result of lengthy and complex negotiations. The Deutsche Welle commentary by Ms Phuong Nguyen is well worth reading carefully. She spells out the possible limitations of the agreement, and the steps which yet need to be completed. She writes: "We should be cautiously optimistic. The deal was only signed between the Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team (NCCT), which represents 16 ethnic armed groups, and the government's peacemaking team. Both sides attached great importance to the latest round of talks. But while the government indicated it was ready to sign the text into a nationwide peace accord, the NCCT calls this a provisional agreement that it still needs to take to the leaders of its member groups for their approval. Also, there were some armed groups that weren't at the table. In addition, the two sides got to this agreement partly by kicking some of the more controversial issues down the road."
It is easy to be cynical and to argue that there is no agreed cease-fire yet in place and that the draft agreement will collapse before it can be signed, which is expected in a matter of weeks. The international community has however given the draft agreement a very warm welcome and promised their full support. There is no illusion though about the difficult road ahead.
China and Myanmar. 'The Economist examines the Kokang crisis
The government’s Union Peacemaking Work Committee will meet with the ethnics’ Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team (NCCT) in mid-March for the seventh round of official talks on an elusive nationwide ceasefire agreement.Both sides have agreed to meet in Rangoon from March 16, according to ethnic and government negotiators. ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
1. Aiming to safeguard sovereignty, unity and territorial integrity on the basis of the peace process; and building a Union based on democratic and federal principles in the spirit of Panglong and in accordance with the outcomes of Political Dialogue to ensure freedom, equality, justice and self determination for all citizens;
2. Striving together at the outset to conclude the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement without delay whilerecognizing that a nationwide ceasefire is vital for the political dialogue process;
3. Establishing a new political culture of ending long-existing armed conflicts and solving grievances through dialogue instead of resorting to force of arms; and striving together to promptly hold an all inclusive political dialogue process;
4. Working together to promptly draft the Framework for Political Dialogue after concluding the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement and commencing political dialogue prior to the 2015 General Elections in accordance with the Framework on Political Dialogue;
5. Undertaking jointly to prevent armed clashes and confrontations between various armed groups and to refrain from taking actions or measures that will harm the peace process;
A senior Chinese diplomat on Sunday clarified China's policy toward its neighbor Myanmar since conflict in northern Myanmar has triggered rumors.In a written interview with Xinhua, Kong Xuanyou, director-general of the Department of Asian Affairs of the Chinese Foreign Ministry, denied any Chinese local authorities' involvement in the conflict.
China has always adhered to the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of other countries, Kong said. No organization or person using Chinese territory would be allowed to undermine the China-Myanmar relationship and stability in border areas, according to Kong. He stressed that China respects Myanmar's sovereignty, territorial integrity.
China upholds non-interference in other countries' internal affairs, let alone military intervention. China has always respected Myanmar's sovereignty and territorial integrity. Even if there were indeed some Chinese nationals participating in the fighting, it would be only an individual act, to which the Chinese government is strongly opposed. As Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying has said, Beijing will never allow any organization or individual to use Chinese territory to undermine China-Myanmar relations or border tranquility. Read more.....
- UWSA: Govt wrong to suggest Wa, China involvement - The Irrawaddy
- More questions than answers in Kokang dilemma: Editorial - The Irrawaddy
- Myanmar military wins rare praise in war with ethnic Chinese rebels - Reuters
- Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei on the unrest - Chinese MFA
- China stresses "non-interference in Myanmar" - Mizzima
- Kokang clashes will not draw Chinese intervention - Michele Penna
Fighting flared on February 9 between the Tatmadaw and MNDAA remnants when Kokang soldiers attacked Myanmar military positions.
“While the state is making all-out efforts for reaching a nationwide ceasefire, the renegade groups of Kokang have ambushed the troops of the Tatmadaw,” the state-run Global New Light of Myanmar (GNLM) said.
On February 13, the GNLM confirmed heavy losses for the Tatmadaw, with 47 killed and a further 73 injured from February 9 - 12.
Ethnic Federalism and the road to peace
Charmaine Craig: Dissent - Fall 2014
The involvement of Western powers and their narrative about Burma are as dangerous to the people of the country as dictatorship has been, because both can serve as a cover for the continued persecution of ethnic groups by the Burma Army. The West needs to exert diplomatic pressure on the Burmese government and insist that violence against ethnic groups is immediately addressed, that constitutional reforms allowing federalism are implemented, and that political dialogue with the various armed and unarmed ethnic groups be a precondition of nationwide ceasefire and broader diplomatic and economic engagement.
- Lawyer raps report on journalist's death, demands new inquiry - Reuters
- 'Firm agreement' made on federal union says President Thein Sein - DVB
- Govt 'doesn't speak the truth': General Gun Maw KIA - DVB
- Army Chief meets KNU, supports stalled ceasefire process - The Irrawaddy
- Burma Army says deadly shelling of rebels was 'unintentional' - The Irrawaddy
- Peace talks in Myanmar jeopardized by killing of rebels: Thomas Fuller NYT
- US Ambassador visits Kachin State - The Irrawaddy
Charlatanism of the KNU and the Tatmadaw
Kanbawza Win: Asian Tribune - 15 October 2014
Contemporary scholars, politicians, statesmen and laymen will be bewildered to find the word Charlatanism between the two antagonistic groups of the Burmese army known as the Tatmadaw and the current KNU (Karen Nation Union). But their actions and declarations clearly indicate their similarity even though they may be at each other’s throat for more than half a century. Continue reading.....
High stakes in Myanmar's peace process
Murray Hiebert and Phuong Nguyen: Asia Sentinel - 22 August 2014
A perceptive and succinct analyis of the ethnic peace process and how the West can assist, this article merits careful reading. The authors conclude:
"In the near to immediate term, it is important that Washington maintains and seeks to expand diplomatic support and assistance programs designed to help foster trust between Myanmar’s ethnic groups and the government, and empower civil society groups to fully participate in the country’s peace-building initiatives and future political dialogue. Myanmar ethnic leaders have said they would like to have U.S. observers, along with representatives from ASEAN, China, Japan, India, Norway, the United Kingdom, and the United Nations, present at the signing of the nationwide cease-fire accord, a call Washington should consider, assuming the government agrees to this grouping.
"Even if the nationwide cease-fire agreement can be reached before the end of the year, the next major challenge will be getting the political dialogue launched and allowing it to take root before President Thein Sein’s current term expires in early 2016. The road to achieving a lasting political solution to Myanmar’s ethnic conflicts will be long and difficult, and it is important that the United States and other countries that are serious about supporting Myanmar’s democratic transition channel as much attention and as many resources as possible to help ensure the peace process stays on track."
- A seat at the table: Divisions emege on peace conference: Myanmar Times
- UNFC crisis and related issues: An analysis by Sai Wansai - Shan Herald
- KNU's participation in umbrella rebel movement in doubt - RFA
- UWSA and NDAA agree to cease-fire deal - RFA
- Ethnic bloc to meet NLD, 88 Gen in Thailand - DVB
- Ethnic leaders want Suu Ky in on ceasefire - The Myanmar Times
The nationwide ceasefire agreement at a glance
Aung Naing Oo: Myanmar Times - 30 July 2014
At 20 pages, with seven chapters and about 120 different points, it’s hard not to agree with the international conflict resolution expert who recently called Myanmar’s draft nationwide ceasefire agreement as the world’s lengthiest ceasefire deal.
Negotiating parties have spent the past nine months coming up with the current version of the agreement. At the beginning of the talks there were several different drafts. It took some time for negotiators to consolidate these into a single document, a feat achieved in April.
The nationwide ceasefire agreement is supposed to be a ceasefire text. To me, it is really more of a political document, and this may explain why it has taken some time to get to where we are now. Continue reading.....
Latest News and Views
- Persecution of Muslims traps Buddhist minority in limbo - Thomson Reuters
- Armed groups and political legitimacy: Ashley South - Myanmar Times
- A Burmese translation of this article by Ashley South
Myanmar President vows to continue to strive for peace
Xinhua - 1 May 2014
Myanmar President U Thein Sein vowed on Thursday to continue to strive for achieving internal peace and improving people's livelihood, saying the success of reform, which is being undertaken, depends on citizens respecting the rule of law and cooperating with the government.
Citing the finalization of the first draft of a single text of the nationwide ceasefire agreement in early April, U Thein Sein underlined in his regular monthly radio speech to the nation that the move represented a step closer to peace, adding a nationwide ceasefire agreement can soon be signed.
Touching on a March violence in the country's western state of Rakhine, U Thein Sein said some lawbreakers were responsible for the riot. "These events are universally unacceptable and should have never happened. We will not accept this kind of behavior and action against the offenders is being taken pursuant to the law," he said.
Latest News and Views
- War and peace: ceasefire talks and the future of the KNU - Myanmar Times
- Govt, army, ethnic groups closing differences, forming new approach - Irrawaddy
- Hearing new voices in the debate on citizenship - The Myanmar Times
- Peace brokers lack a mandate: Bertil Lintner - The Irrawaddy
Amid delays, rivalries divide Burma's ethnic groups
The Irrawaddy - 7 February 2014
The government and ethnic rebel groups will not meet as planned this month for a nationwide ceasefire conference. The meeting has been postponed once again, to March, with ethnic leaders claiming they need more time to negotiate among themselves before presenting their draft ceasefire proposal.
Ethnic leaders say delays in the final stages are to be expected. But under the surface, rivalries between different rebel groups have slowed the process. Continue reading.....
Ethnic nationaliities offer hope for a nationwide ceasefire
Karen News - 26 January 2014
More than one hundred leaders from Burma’s ethnic armed resistance organizations gathered at Law Khee Lar, Karen State from January 20 to 24, 2014 to work out a plan for a proposed nationwide ceasefire agreement with the Burma government. The ethnic leaders met and discussed the future of Burma, including how to set up a federal army in the country. Dubbed a historic ethnic summit, it is a follow-up meeting of the Armed Ethnic Organization Conference held last month in Laiza, the headquarters of the Kachin Independence Organization, in Burma’s north. Continue reading.....
Norway-backed peace initiative 'probably' to end
Hanna Hindstrom: Democratic Voice of Burma - 12 January 2104
The Myanmar Peace Support Initiative (MPSI), a multi-million dollar scheme supporting humanitarian and peace efforts in Burma’s conflict-torn border areas, is currently undergoing an internal review, which is expected to conclude that there is no “added value” in its work, according to its lead consultant.
“In terms of MPSI we want to make sure whatever we do adds value, and there’s a clear sense that if there isn’t we won’t continue,” Charles Petrie told DVB, adding that it was “probably” going to end. He cited “more complex” local circumstances and an influx of other actors as reasons for the decision. Continue reading.....
Visit to the HQ of Shan State Army-South
Global Times (Chinese) - 26 December 2013
“We hope that China will play a role in the peace talks between the Myanmar government and armed ethnic groups. China and Myanmar share a long border. Border stability is in China’s interest.” This is the hope of Yawd Serk, the leader of Myanmar’s Shan State Army-South and the chairman of Shan State Restoration Council. In the past, the Myanmar government has condemned SSA-S as a “terrorist, drug-trafficking organization”. But for the SSA-S, they are only fighting for the equality for the Shan people and the control of a peaceful region.
In early December, reporters from the Global Times travelled 6 hours from Chiang Mai in northern Thailand to Loi Tai Leng, the headquarter of SSA-S located on the Thai-Myanmar border. The living conditions here are extremely poor, but Yawd Serk thinks they occupy an advantageous geographical location against the government military. The goal of SSA-S has shifted from independence to becoming a part of the Union. People in Shan State want peace, and the pace of the peace talks between the government and the armed ethnic groups could be faster. Continue reading in unofficial English translation.....
- KNU airs grievances to President ahead of nation-wide talks - The Irrawaddy
- Inside the peace process: Ashley South - The Myanmar Times
- A former Chin rebel now fights for peace: Ngun Cung Lian - Washington Post
- Framework for ceasefire talks '80% in place' says observer - DVB
Ethnic Conflict in Burma/Myanmar: From Aspirations to Solutions
Seminar Report: Transnational Institute/Burma Centrum Nederland November 2015
In November, TNI/BCN hosted a two-day seminar, involving ethnic groups from different regions of Burma, on the theme of “Ethnic Conflict in Burma/Myanmar: From Aspirations to Solutions”. Those participating included 20 representatives from Burmese civil society, political and armed opposition groups.
The seminar focused on four main areas: political reform; moving from ceasefires to political dialogue; land rights and natural resource extraction; and ethnic identity and citizenship.
The seminar concluded that political transition continues to be military-dominated and top-down, with essentially the same ruling elite in political and economic authority as under the former State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) regime. Hopes remain that, through political negotiation, democratic reforms will be achieved which lead to just and inclusive solutions. But as the countdown to the 2015 general election begins, concerns are growing that essential reforms will not be delivered. Read the full report.....
Derek Tonkin writes: The report reflects the perceptions only of those who took part in the seminar and who mostly seem to have come from the Burmese Diaspora. The international community at large is criticised "for apparently accepting the 2008 constitution as the solution to the country's needs and challenges", for failing "to understand the nature of Burma's ethnic crises" and for other inadequacies relating to the forthcoming national census and international aid policies. UN agencies particularly come in for criticism, as does UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon himself and the Myanmar Peace Center. The international community would no doubt generally dispute this temperamental and jaundiced analysis, though the issues raised are very real and need resolution.
- Burma's opium production has hit record levels - TIME 19 December 2013
- If you're Karen and you know it : Banyan - The Economist 15 November 2013
Negotiations between Government and Ethnic Armed Organizations
- Peace negotiator foresees breakthrough at next talks - Xinhua
- Myanmar Government, ethnic groups fail to make breakthrough - Xinhua
- No fixed time yet for ceasefire: KIO Maj Gen Gwan Maw - Eleven Media
- Video transcript - Lt Gen Myint Soe interviewed by Democratic Voice of Burma
- Statement by UN Special Adviser Vijay Nambiar on the Myitkyina talks - UNIC
- Ethnic Armed Organizations - Union Peace-Making Work Committee - Kachin News
- Myitkyina talks show obstacles on the path of peace process - The Irrawaddy
- Nationwide ceasefire, political dialogue appear on the horizon - DVB
- Burma opens national ceasefire talks with ethnic rebel groups - VOA
- Ethnic groups sign accord aimed at nationwide ceasfire - DVB
- Nationwide Ceasefire Accord: Not the End Game - Burma Partnership
- All but one ethnic groups support signing ceasefire agreement - The Irrawaddy
Thein Sein calls for peace, insists on national unity
Mizzima - 30 October 2013
President Thein Sein called on leaders of ethnic armed groups to work with the government to ensure both national peace and unity in a letter to the gathering of the groups that began yesterday in Laiza. U Thein Sein said in the 29 October letter that the conference is critical. He said he supported a single, nationwide ceasefire accord as well as the adoption of a framework for building peace through political dialogue.
The conference, the first of its kind, is begin held in Laiza, the headquarters of the Kachin Independence Organization. The KIO is sponsoring the conference, which aims to reach a nationwide ceasefire accord with the Union government.
Groups attending it include: the United Nationalities Federal Council, New Mon State Party, Shan State Progressive Party/Shan State Army, Palaung State Liberation Front, Karenni National Progressive Party, Karen National Union, Democratic Karen Benevolence Army, Restoration Council for Shan State/Shan State Army South, Abakan Liberation Party, All Burma Students’ Democratic Front, Pa-O National Liberation Organization and Karen National Liberation Front/Peace Council.
- Great expectations: UN optimistic about peace talks - The Myanmar Times
- Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement: Myanmar's road to peace - Aung Naing Oo
- Myanmar's drive for peace - Maung Zarni
- Thousands greet convoy of ethnic leaders in Myitkyina - The Irrawaddy
Myanmar's Shan see long path to peace
Larry Jagan: Asia Times Online - 6 September 2013
In an exclusive interview, Shan Lt Gen Yawd Serk predicted it would take at least three years to complete the first stage - a proper ceasefire agreement and an end to all fighting - and probably another six years before a final political solution could be achieved. This solution, Yawd Serk insists, would mean a new federal constitution that allows for self-determination in ethnic areas, the protection of ethnic rights and the preservation of ethnic culture.
"We want real peace, we want a political solution, and we want all ethnic groups to participate," Yawd Serk said, referring to the other ethnic armies that have fought for decades against the central government. "First the fighting has to stop and agreement reached on the areas each side controls."Continue reading.....
Federalism debate fractures Burma's armed ethnic groups
Hanna Hindstrom: Democratic Voice of Burma - 30 July 2013
Burma’s armed ethnic groups have fallen out over how to develop a federal union in the former military dictatorship, resulting in two rival conferences to discuss plans to end decades of civil conflict.
Inside sources say that a split has emerged between “hard-liners” and those who favour compromising with the government to amend the military-drafted 2008 constitution, which currently grants Naypyidaw control over ethnic minority territories.
The dispute has contributed to a major rift in Burma’s ethnic movement, culminating in Burma’s leading ethnic umbrella group, the United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC), severing ties with the multi-ethnic Working Group for Ethnic Coordination (WGEC), which was set up to coordinate negotiations with Naypyidaw, in June.
The UNFC is currently hosting an ethnic nationalities conference in Chiang Mai, northern Thailand, to discuss federalism and strategies for political dialogue. Meanwhile, the WGEC is planning a similar event in mid-August, which analysts say might “cause confusion” among the ethnic populations. Continue reading.....
- EBO Briefing Paper: Analysis of the UNFC position
- Constitution rewrite push from ethnic groups 'radical' - The Myanmar Times
- UNFC Conference stresses need for nationwide peace - The Irrawaddy
- 2008 Charter dumped by UNFC Conference in Chiang Mai - Shan Herald
- Political sequence, legitimacy and bargaining in Burma - Sai Wansai, Shan Herald
Karen-Shan Alliance: The Lady too important as stakeholder to be mediator
Shan Herald - 18 July 2013
A joint statement issued yesterday by the Karen National Union (KNU) and the Restoration Council of Shan State (RCSS), apparently in response to the United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC) proposal on Saturday, 13 July 2013, said mediation between armed ethnic groups and the Thein Sein government would not be fair if conducted by National League for Democracy (NLD) leader Aung San Suu Kyi because she is a key stakeholder in the peace process.
“The dialogue process in Burma is very complicated, with multiple stakeholders simultaneously involved. This is not conducive to use of a single mediator. To overcome this situation, the National Dialogue process designed by ethnic armed groups enables all stakeholders to address their concerns without the use of mediators. As the process matures, stakeholders can request to utilize mediators or facilitators for specific discussions. Normally, stakeholders do not act as mediators or facilitators,” read the statement.
Derek Tonkin writes: The Myanmar Government plans to invite all ethnic groups to a nationwide cease-fire ceremony in the near future. Competing interests have however made the task somewhat complicated. The UNFC is seen by some as a hard-line expatriate group seeking to exert a measure of control over the peace process, which is unlikely to be acceptable to the Government and in-country ethnic interests.
- Burma signs treaty with Wa ethnic group - BBC Asia
- Deciphering Myanmar's peace process: A Reference Guide 2013
- Cease-fire must lead to political discussions: President - Eleven Media
- Rain for Myanmar's peace parade - Bertil Lintner, Asia Times
- Fifteen ethnic groups to form unified party - RFA/AFP
A tentative peace in Myanmar's Kachin conflict
International Crisis Group: Asia Briefing No. 140 - 12 June 2013
In its latest briefing, A Tentative Peace in Myanmar’s Kachin Conflict, the International Crisis Group examines the peace agreement that the Myanmar government signed with the Kachin Independence Organisation (KIO), the last of the eleven major armed ethnic groups to sign an agreement since 2011. This represents a major opportunity to secure lasting peace not only in Kachin State, but in the country as a whole. Yet, there will be major challenges in doing so.
This is a major step forward. Securing a sustainable peace will not be easy, and depends on more detailed negotiations in three main areas - force separation, a monitoring and verification mechanism, and a dialogue on political issues. The 30 May agreement is the beginning of a process of consolidating peace, not the end. Without further progress, a resumption of armed conflict is possible.
- Overview in English
- Overview in Burmese
- Text of full report in English
- Text of full report in Burmese
Derek Tonkin writes: There are some important judgements in this informative and perceptive analysis to which attention should be drawn:
- Tensions boiled over in late 2012 "after the regime took a series of confrontational steps towards the KIO". (Page 7)
- The meeting at Ruili on 30 August 2012 "turned out to be a disaster" when none of the senior KIO leaders attended. (Pages 9-10)
- The renewed fighting in late December 2012 "raised questions about the extent to which the President has authority over the armed forces", but "it is not clear that there is any significant divergence between the President and the military, much less that the military is actively disobeying the President's decrees……the President would have had difficulty preventing the military from taking action to secure its positions." (Pages 11-12)
- China "remained opposed to any US or UK involvement, but changed its stance on UN participation. (Page 17)
- "The level of attention now being given to the ethnic issue by the US, UK and broader international community is unprecedented." (page 17)
- "Beijing is resolute about continuing to block any substantive involvement of the US or the UK in what it sees as an issue relating to its border security." (Page18)
- "However, this agreement is a ceasefire in all but name." (Page 18)
- "The sale of jade - all of which is mined in Kachin State - is estimated to have reached as much as $10 billion annually, which would make it by far Myanmar's largest export commodity." (Page 19)
Kachin Peace Talks
- Statement by the EU High Representative on the Myanmar-Kachin Agreement
- KIO, Government sign preliminary agreement - The Irrawaddy
- Parties upbeat as Day One of Kachin Peace Talks closes - The Irrawaddy
- UN Special Envoy, Chinese Observers attend Kachin Peace Talks - The Irrawaddy
- Thousands greet Kachin delegation ahead of peace talks in Myitkyina - DVB
New Mandala - 16 April 2013
Sai Latt argues that: "As a first step, Burma needs a group of Burmese (however one wants to define this) who dare to challenge ingrained state ideologies and constitutive elements that perpetuate colonial attitudes and actions. This means, challenging the very notions of the state, nation, nationalism and sovereignty, and addressing the actions of those in power at different sites and scales. Without it, all the talk about peace is just a waste of time and energy; it will fail one day or another." Continue reading.....
Powers seek influence in Burma's conflict
- Ethnic Council, Government etch out plans for dialogue - Democratic Voice of Burma
- Myanmar Peace Process - EBO Briefing Paper January 2013
Years of guerrilla warfare produced excellent Kachin, Kayin and Shan military leaders but they turned out to be poor political strategists, unable to agree a common vision for a peaceful Burmese political union. As for the Bamar, few are prepared to question the dominant view of the Burmese nation as an exclusive, almost endogamous, racial community, whose religion is Buddhism. Rethinking the idea of the nation is essential, especially since the ethnic question is linked to territory, and therefore the economy.
The disagreement within the Karen leadership is believed to have begun during the second round of peace talks in Pa-an between the government’s peace delegation and the KNU central committee led by David Taw on 12 January when a ceasefire was signed.
Derek Tonkin writes: This internal dissension is unwelcome to the Government who wish to move on from the cease-fire agreement signed in January. At root would seem to be a clash of personalities.
Myanmar will make 'all necessary compromises' for peace
Yesterday’s two-hour long meeting was attended by the KNU general secretary Naw Zipporah Sein, Padoh Saw Thawthi Bwe, Naw May Oo and Saw Aung Win Shwe and the government’s delegation was led by Railways Minister U Aung Min, Immigration Minister U Khin Ye, U Soe Thein and the Karen State Minister,U Zaw Min. In addition to the government delegation, ‘peace mediators’ with links to the business and lobby sector included Dr. Kyaw Yin Hlaing, U Hla Maung Shwe, U Tin Maung Than from Myanmar Egress Company, U Ngwe Soe, U Ko Ko Maung and his wife Ma Su from Dawei Princess Company attended yesterday’s meeting.
Suu Kyi and the contradictions of State
William Lloyd-George - The Diplomat Blog - 30 June 2012
The writer, a noted free-lance journalist based in Thailand, examines ethnic problems facing Suu Kyi in Myanmar. He reports that: "As a result of Suu Kyi’s lack of condemnation, the Kachin community decided to boycott a celebration between all ethnic groups in the U.K. on Suu Kyi’s final day. 'We have nothing to celebrate, our people are dying, and starving; we should be condemning the military regime, not dancing and singing. There is still a lot of work to do, it is not yet time to rejoice,' said Ko Nawng, a Kachin student studying in London."
"The Kachin are not the only community in the U.K., or back in Burma, who are unhappy with Suu Kyi. To voice their disappointment with Suu Kyi’s opinion on the sectarian violence taking place in Arakan State, the Rohingya community also boycotted Suu Kyi’s farewell event. 'We are not happy with the way Suu Kyi has spoken about the situation,' says Tun Kin, Director of the Burmese Rohingya Organization in London." Read more.....
- Failed path to peace in Myanmar- Bertil Lintner, Asia Times
- Government and KIA to hold informal talks - The Irrawaddy
- Norway defends peace initiative in conflict zones - Hanna Hindstrom, DvB
Text of Agreement with Chin National Front - The Chinland Guardian
- Why cease-fires fail in Myanmar - Francis Wade, Asia Times
- KNU Chief calls for close scrutiny of Myanmar - Interview with The Nation (Bangkok)
Agence France-Presse - 10 May 2012
A bold move by Myanmar's president to take charge of peace talks with ethnic rebels has revived hope of an end to a war in the far north perpetuated by mutual distrust and vested interests, experts say. Conflict between Myanmar's army and ethnic rebels in Kachin state has raged for a year, displacing around 50,000 civilians and casting a shadow over hard-won government ceasefires in other parts of the country. The reformist regime has now overhauled its negotiating team, putting the president at the helm of the process and removing some elements of the previous delegation seen by Kachin rebels as linked to army hardliners.
Experts Nicholas Farrelly (Australian National University), Win Min (Vahu Development Institute in Thailand) and Richard Horsey (independent analyst) express their views on these welcome developments.
- Myanmar to beef-up peace effort to end Kachin conflict - Reuters
- Myanmar leader reshuffles peace team - Agence France-Presse
- Thein Sein's drug problem - Brian McCartan, Asia Times
- Ethnic alliance ready to meet Government negotiator - Shan Herald
- Shan leader talks to David Cameron - Shan Herald
- Ethnic representaties meet British Prime Minister - Kaladan Press
Shan Herald - 9 April 2012
Sai Wansai, General Secretary of the Shan Democratic Union, reflects on recent dramatic changes in Myanmar and concludes that: "All in all, the prospect of democratisation and achieving peace have never been so good for the past few decades. In practical terms, as many analyses have pointed out, the smooth process of democratisation will hinge on whether the newly elected MPs will be treated fairly in the USDP dominated parliament, continuing reform process leading to a free and fair election due to be held in 2015, ethnic conflict resolution and the degree of press and opinion freedom of expression be further improved to an accepted international standard."
Sai Wansai reveals: President Thein Sein "reportedly said, during his meeting with the Karen National Union (KNU) delegation on 8 April in Naypyitaw, that he considered the KNU as his brethren [rather] than enemy and that the constitution could be amended to give a fair share of political decision-making power for all the non-Burman ethnic groups. This is a far cry from the successive military regimes’ unspoken “total elimination” doctrine, which is deeply rooted in the military mindset."
- Transcript of President Thein Sein's remarks to the KNU - Mizzima
- Myanmar President invites Karen rebels to form political party - DPA
- Government, Karen rebels agree on cease-fire, talks will continue - Associated Press
- With peace in Shan State, economy should progress: Thein Sein - Mizzima
- Decades-old ethnic wars take on new profile - Denis Gray, Associated Press
- They don't want democracy, the want freedom - Stanley Weiss, Huffington Post
- New Mon State Party and Government sign peace agreement - The Irrawaddy
TNI Burma Policy Briefing No. 8 - February 2012
Since the end of 2011, Burma/Myanmar’s government has held peace talks with all major ethnic armed opposition groups in the country. The talks represent a much needed change from the failed ethnic policies of the last decades. They are a first important step by the new military-backed Thein Sein government, which came into power in March 2011, towards achieving national reconciliation and peace in the country, which has been divided by civil war since independence in 1948. By February 2012, initial peace agreements had been reached with most ethnic armed opposition groups.
However, in order to end the civil war and achieve true ethnic peace, the current talks must move beyond establishing new cease-fires. It is vital that the process is followed by an inclusive political dialogue at the national level, and that key ethnic grievances and aspirations are addressed. Failure to do so will undermine the current reform process in the country and lead to a continuation of Burma’s cycle of conflict.
Reuters - 15 February 2012
Peace with the rebels, most of whom demand autonomy under what they call a "genuine federal system", has been set by the United States and the European Union as a condition for lifting sanctions on the former Burma, an underdeveloped but resource-rich country that has wilted under international isolation and inept army rule.But Aung Min said the government's motive was not the lifting of sanctions. Nine of 16 rebel groups had signed ceasefire agreements with the government and he expected six more deals to be reached within a few months, including with the Kachin Independence Army (KIA), one of the biggest groups, which the Myanmar military is still fighting.
- Ending Myanmar's civil war - Michael Lwin, Peking University
- Federalist Reform for Burma - Benedict Rogers, Wall Street Journal
- Thein Sein vows to end Burma's civil war - Democratic Voice of Burma
- KNU divided over peace treaty - The Irrawaddy
- In Myanmar Karen rebels deny signing a cease-fire - New York Times
- US decries worsened violence in Kachin State - Agence France-Presse
- Burma's Kachin Challenge - Trefor Moss, The Diplomat blog
- New Mon State Party signs preliminary agreement with Government
- Reuters video - Karen troops come in from the cold
The Stimson Center is a non-profit, non-partisan institution devoted to enhancing international peace and security.
Chinland Guadrian - 12 January 2012
As Aung San Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy Party (NLD) decides to re-enter the Burmese political scene, many of the ethnic parties who have stood by the NLD and joined the boycott of the 2010 elections are now in a dilemma. Chinland Guardian’s Salai Nyein Chan talked to Pu Cin Sian Thang of the Zomi National Congress in this exclusive interview. A veteran Chin politician and leader of the Zomi National Congress who was elected in the 1990 elections, Pu Cin Sian Thang has spent a lifetime in Burmese politics.
Myanmar Government and Karen National Union sign pact
Channel News Asia - 11 January 2012
Myanmar's government and one of the country's most prominent ethnic rebel groups signed a ceasefire on Thursday after decades of fighting, the latest in the country's apparent bids to reform. A delegation of ministers from the capital Naypyidaw and senior members of the Karen National Union (KNU) signed the pact in Hpa-an, the capital of eastern Karen state, scene of one of the world's longest-running civil wars. "The president has said we brothers have been angry at each other for 63 years and he asked us to give the KNU what they want. That's why we came here," said Immigration Minister Khin Yi before the pact was signed in front of reporters.